Google AI Overviews ranks sources partly on freshness and topical authority, but stale government pages often carry institutional weight. Your best move is to make your content unmissably current and authoritative through aggressive schema markup and strategic content updates.
Start this week: audit the specific queries where you're appearing alongside outdated sources. Use Google Search Console to see which queries trigger your pages in AI Overviews, then search those queries yourself to see which stale pages rank alongside you. Document the gap—what information is wrong or missing in those old sources?
Next, add FAQPage schema markup to your donor resources and financial aid guides if you haven't already. Include the publication date and last modified date in your schema, and update that modified date whenever you refresh even a paragraph. Google's systems observe recency signals in schema more reliably than in plain text.
Then, create or refresh one high-value piece of content that directly contradicts or supersedes the outdated guidance. For example, if old pages cite expired income thresholds for aid eligibility, publish a dated guide titled "2025 Financial Aid Guidelines" with current numbers prominently featured. Link it internally from your existing pages.
Within two weeks, re-run those searches. You won't always displace institutional pages, but fresh, well-marked content with current data tends to shift Google's citation weight toward your brand over time.